skip to main content

FAQ

FAQs 2024

Not necessarily. However, as with most things related to Form 5500 reporting, ultimate decision-making authority in this regard will rest with the plan administrator.

The Form 5500 filing requirement for health and welfare plans subject to ERISA is straightforward: all such plans with 100 or more plan participants on the first day of the plan year must file Form 5500 for that plan year, including all applicable insurance information on Schedule A.

Schedule A reporting can be a challenge for plan administrators because it relies upon the delivery of Schedule A information from insurance carriers (and, occasionally, other entities such as point solutions vendors) to the plan. While insurance carriers have an obligation to provide Schedule A information, plans will still occasionally find themselves having to chase it down themselves (an earlier FAQ addressed this problem).

Sometimes, however, the opposite problem can arise, where plans receive Schedule A information that was neither requested nor expected, and this can come as an unwelcome surprise to plan administrators who may not have previously considered filing Form 5500 for this particular benefit.

In these instances, it’s worth remembering that the carrier in question may subscribe to the “when-in-doubt-send-it-out” school of Schedule A information reporting. That is, rather than trying to sort out which of their customers need Schedule A information to file Form 5500 and which ones do not, the carrier simply fulfills its obligation to those who do need the information by sending it to all of its customers. Those who need it for Form 5500 reporting will use it for that purpose, and those who do not need it will not use it. From the carrier’s standpoint, its job is done either way.

A carrier may also send out Schedule A information as a matter of practice if its benefit covers 100 or more persons, and this is often a result of Form 5500’s rather confusing treatment of “participants” for reporting purposes on the one hand and “covered persons” for purposes of Schedule A on the other.

Form 5500’s “participant” count includes only participating employees and former employees and does not include spouses and dependents. By contrast, Schedule A’s “covered persons” count includes covered spouses and dependents along with covered employees. Nevertheless, some carriers will send Schedule A information by virtue only of having 100 or more “covered persons” under the benefit, regardless of whether all of those “covered persons” for purposes of the benefit are also “participants” for purposes of Form 5500 reporting.

Whatever the carrier’s reasons for doing so may be, its provision of Schedule A information does not in and of itself obligate a plan administrator to report that information on Form 5500. But neither should a plan administrator simply ignore the information altogether. Rather, the plan administrator should take that opportunity to take reasonable steps to confirm their belief that no Form 5500 reporting is required for the benefit. The specific steps to take would depend on their rationale for that belief.

The most common such rationales include:

The benefits are “voluntary.” The plan administrator should ensure that any benefits they consider “voluntary” for purposes of ERISA (and therefore not subject to Form 5500 reporting), truly meet the DOL’s voluntary plan safe harbor requirements. These generally require that the employer’s functions regarding the program are only to allow an insurer to offer and publicize its program to employees, collecting premiums through after-tax payroll deductions and remitting these premiums to the insurer.

Furthermore, employers must not put any conditions on an employee’s election of benefits nor profit from the program, and the employer must be very careful not to take any actions that either expressly or implicitly endorse the program, including:

  • Assisting employees with preparation of claim forms
  • Negotiating with insurers
  • Recordkeeping (other than maintaining a list of enrolled employees)
  • Permitting payroll deductions to be made on a pre-tax basis under the employer’s cafeteria plan

The benefit has fewer than 100 participants. In such case, the plan administrator should ensure that the benefit is not included with other component benefits (e.g., under a “wrap plan”) that has 100 or more participants. Otherwise, this benefit would generally be reportable along with those other benefits on the Form 5500 for that plan. (See our previous FAQ on this topic here.)

The benefit is not insurance. Certain programs (sometimes called “point solutions”) that provide benefits for specific conditions (e.g., infertility, obesity, mental health, etc.) may not present like traditional insurance offerings, but they may still be “insurance” for purposes of Schedule A reporting. As a general proposition, point solutions vendors can be reluctant to provide Schedule A information to plan administrators, even when asked to do so. Therefore, plan administrators who receive Schedule A information unprompted from its point solutions vendor should consider that as a strong indicator that the program in question is indeed reportable on Schedule A. (See our previous FAQ on this topic here.)

As stated at the beginning, the ultimate decision as to whether to report Schedule A information on Form 5500 is the plan administrator’s to make, preferably with the advice of experienced counsel for situations that are just too close to make a solid call in one direction or the other. But the mere receipt of Schedule A information alone does not necessarily give rise to any Schedule A reporting obligation.

NFP Corp. and its subsidiaries do not provide legal or tax advice. Compliance, regulatory and related content is for general informational purposes and is not guaranteed to be accurate or complete. You should consult an attorney or tax professional regarding the application or potential implications of laws, regulations or policies to your specific circumstances.